Sam Trenholme's webpage
Support this website or listen to my music

A brief look at systemd


January 21 2013

In today's blog, I look at systemd, the program that will replace init in Red Hat and CentOS 7, from the point of view of a software developer.

The problem

UNIX's traditional way of starting daemons -- usually called "System V init" -- is something of a hack. SysVinit simply calls a bunch of shell scripts at system boot up time to start all of the processes.

This leaves process management to each program. MaraDNS, for example, has three different 100-line shell scripts to manage the starting and stopping of MaraDNS processes, and a nearly 300-line C program (duende) which handles making MaraDNS a UNIX daemon ("service" in Windows' parlance) and logging MaraDNS' messages.

Much to Nicholas Bamber's annoyance, the way daemons are managed on Red Hat/CentOS 6 (the system I develop MaraDNS on) is somewhat different than the way Debian (the system Nicholas ports MaraDNS to) handles processes, which makes the port more difficult than it should be.

SysVInit has other annoyances. For example, a single daemon that, for whatever reason, takes a while to start up will slow down the boot process for the entire system. Sendmail is notorious for sometimes taking minutes to start up; it's a very frustrating experience watching a system boot stall until Sendmail is finally running.

Some old solutions

Software developers have been coming up with different ways to move beyond the limitations of SysVInit. DJB developed daemontools, Python developers developed supervisord, I developed duende, and so on.

Pretty soon, a UNIX server can be running a number of different "daemonizing" programs that all do more or less the same thing: Starting, stopping, restarting, and logging processes.

This kind of fragmentation is a headache for system administrators, who now have to learn multiple ways of handling processes on their system. It also means that each "home grown" solution will not be as well-developed as a single unified solution. Duende, for example, only respawns a terminated process under certain circumstances which are hard-wired in its C source code.


This brings us to systemd. Systemd is a single unified daemon which replaces init on new Linux systems. It will allow me to replace 3 100-line shell scripts and a 300-line "daemonizing" program (which spawns three processes per daemon) with a single configuration file about a dozen lines long.

It replaces a menagerie of different daemonizers with a single clean, elegant, centrally maintained init replacement. It will make it easier for me to maintain MaraDNS, because I will be able to concentrate on the central daemon that processes DNS queries instead of worrying about how its daemonization is handled in a given Linux distribution.

Systemd is a much-needed step forward for Linux servers. I am glad Red Hat is making this transition.

IPv6 update

While my BuyVM node is now happily in Nevada, IPv6 doesn't route on this node yet. My web pages are currently only accessible on IPv4. I will keep readers updated. Update: IPv6 is good

To post a comment about an entry, send me an email and I may or may not post your comment (with or without editing)

Previous entry Next entry Blog index